Pop Tart Ice Cream Sandwich recipe made with strawberry Pop Tarts and ice cream is the perfect easy summer treat.

Jump to:

Easy Pop Tart ice cream recipe

Pop Tart Ice Cream Sandwiches are simply quick, delicious, nostalgic desserts that are perfect for summer.

This super easy strawberry Pop Tart recipe is like handheld strawberry pie ala mode that’s made in minutes!

And although there are lots of fresh strawberry recipes and recipes using frozen strawberries on this site. This is not one of those strawberry recipes.

This strawberry recipe is made from simply strawberry Pop Tarts and ice cream.

Of course, you could throw some fresh sliced strawberries in there for good measure I suppose.

Ingredients

Strawberry Pop Tarts – Pop Tarts make a delicious alternative ice cream sandwich cookie because they maintain a firm but pie crust like texture after freezing. And they come complete with both a flavor filling and typically icing and decorations on top. Try mixing up the Pop Tart variety and ice cream flavors to make your own easy creative ice cream sandwich flavor combinations.
Ice cream – vanilla ice cream, strawberry ice cream, coconut ice cream or any other ice cream flavor you desire. You can use blueberry gelato, homemade strawberry swirl ice cream or summer berry ice cream.

Cut ice cream layer. If using homemade ice cream spread on frozen sheet pans and freeze solid. Then cut into rectangles to fit the Pop Tarts. Or if using store bought ice cream in paper cartons simply slice through the cartons to cut ice cream into desired thickness then trim ice cream into rectangles.
Layer cut ice cream between two strawberry Pop Tarts.
Place on a single layer on a large platter or sheet pan.
Freeze again until solid, wrapping in parchment paper and twine, if desired.
Serve as is or cut each Strawberry Pop Tart Ice Cream Sandwich in halves or thirds.

Pop Tart Strawberry Ice Cream Sandwich recipe made with strawberry Pop Tarts and ice cream is the perfect easy summer treat.

Prep Time: 30

Cook Time: 2

Freezing Time: 1

Total Time: 1 32

Course: Dessert

Cuisine: American

Servings: servings

Author: Tristin Rieken

Cut ice cream layer. Slice through ice cream cartons to cut ice cream into desired thickness then trim ice cream into rectangles. Or spread ice cream on frozen sheet pans and freeze until solid, then cut into rectangles.
½ gallon vanilla ice cream
Layer cut ice cream between two strawberry Pop Tarts.
12 whole Strawberry Pop Tarts
Place on a single layer on a large platter or sheet pan.
Freeze again until solid, wrapping in parchment paper and twine, if desired.
Serve as is or cut each Strawberry Pop Tart Ice Cream Sandwich in halves or thirds.

Made this recipe? Please share!Mention @freshflavorful or tag #FreshFlavorfulLife